I had another theory the other day about why Perth is so backwards.
We all look on at cities like Melbourne and Sydney and talk about how progressive and fantastically busy they are whilst all the while bagging how dull Perth is. Well you may not have, but I’ve heard many people that have.
I have a theory that Perth remains behind the times because it’s size lends it to being influenced heavily by Industry groups.
We recently had a referendum on extended trading for shopping and have had many referendums for daylight savings that have failed. Politicians have even come out to say that referendums don’t work because people will conservatively vote for the no rather than the yes, people on the whole fear change (or more to the point like to remain in a comfortable state).
It always seems that whenever we have these polls on social issues Industry Groups always come out with some sort of sob story that usually completely disregard simple economic theory.
For the last extended trading referendum we had the “small shop owners” such as dewsons and supa value complaining that they would lose business to the BIG CORPORATIONS such as woolies and coles, despite the fact that simple market economics states that people will shop where it is convenient, there is a good range and it’s cheapest, so if people stop going to your stores it’s because you’re not competing well enough in those key areas. Nonetheless everyone bought the sob story and voted no.
Come 2006, the Government just bypassed public opinion and made a daylight savings trial (huzzah) which i think has already been a great success. They also allowed sunday trading for bottle shops and soon will allow small bar licenses for bars with less than 120 people to emulate more cosmopolitan cities such as Melbourne. But wait… the Associated Hotels Association had to come up with it’s latest sob story saying that “its a sad day for small WA family-owned hotels, many of which relied on the extra bottle shop trade on sundays to stay afloat”.
OH my poor bleeding heart, how I pity those small family owned hotels such as the Queens, the Inglewood, the Hyde Park Hotel, the Herdsman and the Wembley to name but a few. Those poor people who couldn’t possibly be making a profit from actual visitors to their pubs, but are JUST scraping by selling alcohol from their bottle shops and only just staying afloat.
SOMEHOW, I JUST DONT THINK SO.
What about those poor family owned bottle shop forced to close on weekends and lose many of their customers to the rather larger hotels because they are forced to close on Sundays?